Dune 2 Galactic Boogaloo

I don't like sand. It's coarse and rough and irritating and it
gets everywhere, even in your stillsuit.
dir: Denis Villeneuve
2024
When they announced that Dune Part II was going to be released this year, I was like “oh, yeah, that” having pretty much completely forgotten about the first part.
Don’t get me wrong, or, get me wrong if you really want, I didn’t dislike the first part, in fact I thought it was pretty good / okay. It seemed pretty faithful to the book, and ignored more of the boring bits and felt somehow expansive and fleet at the same time.
I’ll be really honest with you: At the time when it came out we were in the midst of lockdowns, so anything vaguely good was like cool water to someone dying of thirst. All it needed was cool visuals and nice music, and I was ready to praise it to the high heavens and the lowest hells.
It’s not lost on me, or anyone of a certain age, that Dune is sci-fi Lawrence of Arabia. But even knowing that, and having a liking for desert cinematography, that’s not the only charm or the point of watching this flick.
Because of the built in “white saviour” narrative, this flick, very much unlike the great one from the 80s directed by David Lynch, of all people, worries about its main character being a super messiah, instead of accepting it as an inherently good thing (for our heroes).
What ensues is a narrative in which someone will say Paul (Timothee Chalamet) is the prophesied messiah of the Fremen people, and then someone will say either “no he’s not” or “that’s just what they want you to think, so they can control us” and then “is so”, and then “nuh uh”.
It’s exhausting. It transcends it merely being “meta”, in that the screenplay and the makers anticipating audience reactions to white saviour narratives are constantly signposting that they know it’s a white saviour narrative, and so they try to undercut it or emphasise it (by having the whole messiah prophecy idea being one the arch-manipulators, the Bene Gesserit order, have artificially implanted within Fremen culture), in ways that are very repetitive.
- Read more about Dune 2 Galactic Boogaloo
- 1267 reads








