Poor Things
We are all, in some ways, our own unholy creations
dir: Yorgos Lanthimos
2023
I remember being amazed at the success of Yorgos Lanthimos several years ago when The Favourite became so feted and popular, getting all the awards and plaudits and … does anyone even remember The Favourite now? I mean, sure, it only came out in 2018, but that feels like a hundred years ago now.
I guess what I found so surprising is that all the weird goofiness of how Lanthimos puts his films together wasn’t enough to dissuade audiences or lose Olivia Colman an Oscar for Best Actress.
And if anyone thinks the path of an idiosyncratic director is to become less idiosyncratic as the budgets get bigger and the casts more A-List, well, I don’t think that’s the path he’s on at the moment. If anything…
Poor Things, if it was watched by a lot of people last year, and if it’s watched by more people on streaming etc this year, will be one of the weirdest flicks many people have seen in a good long while. And that’s not just the subject matter or the frequent uses of fish eye anamorphic lenses that make certain scenes look like they were filmed through someone’s front door peephole.
Maybe there’s a bit lifted from Frankenstein, but I don’t think thematically it has as much in common, at all. Man’s hubris in seeking to be like God by creating life is not questioned here; there’s no cautionary aspect. Our creation here, being Bella Baxter (Emma Stone), is not the monster, even if her creation is a ghastly act of unholy Science run amok.
It’s based on a book, by Alisdair Gray, which I have not read, but looking at the list of books he’s written, he seems like an absolute Scottish legend, and I’d be more than curious to read the one this is based on, as well as the others.
I think the only acknowledgement they make of the story’s Scottish origins is the appallingly inconsistent attempt at a Scottish accent that Willem Dafoe assays playing the character of God(win) Baxter, Bella’s creator. It’s like he starts a sentence and then towards the end of it remembers “oh yeah, I’m meant to be doing an accent” and then throws a big of a brogue over the last syllables. It’s so comical that I couldn’t even tell if it was deliberate on the director’s part, or whether he just gave up.
- Read more about Poor Things
- 516 reads