My Favourite Cake
My favourite cake, to be honest, is all of them
(کیک محبوب من,
Keyk-e mahbub-e man)
dirs. Maryam Moghaddam & Behtash Sanaeeha
2024
I’ve been thinking about it for a while and I’m not even sure what my favourite cake would be, but I don’t think you’ll be surprised if I lead with the fact that this flick is probably, despite its title, not about cake or cakes in general.
It’s about contemporary life in Tehran under the regime, and how depressing it is, independent of how life for a widow or widower can be sad or lonely without enough to keep you occupied in between cakes. And it’s not just the matter of community expectations, or conservative cultural morays, or of the actual literal Morality Police who patrol the streets and kill women for allowing their hair to be visible.
Mahin (Lily Farhadpour) remembers the city before the revolution. She remembers how people partied, and danced, and sang. But that was so long ago. She also remembers when her husband was alive, which was also a long time ago, thirty years to be precise. Her children have grown up, and fled this totalitarian nightmare, and she is alone. Alone, bored, lonely, craving human contact and perhaps human touch. She has trouble sleeping so naturally stays up late into the night watching trashy romantic dramas, and then sleeps in until noon, most days.
She still has some friends (alive). All women, obviously, since friendship or contact with a non-relative male would probably get you arrested at the very least. And they are all widows too, who get together and nostalgise in between complaining about their physical ailments.
Being 70, her freedom is a little bit physically limited, but the bigger limitations are ever present, and invisible, except when characters choose to make themselves emblematic, and then those limitations become more literal. She hears conflict, when having visited a park, of a girl being harassed by the Morality Police, who are trying to drag her into a van because she’s not wearing her hijab properly. She fearlessly pushes back at one of the MoPos, telling him how dare he pick on innocent women for no good reason, and doesn’t he have a mother himself, how would she feel if she saw him brutalising women?
His retort is “ah, you must be one of these women that provokes the Morality Police and then get someone else to film it on their phones, and then post it to social media”, which must be a very standard response, and you’d have to think the perfect retort would be “We didn’t make you dumb goons kill Mahsa Jina Amini, you clods did that all on your lonesome”, and all that followed in the Woman Life Freedom protests that ensued.
It makes me, unfortunately, think of the old phrase “the beatings will continue until moral improves”, a process which started just after the revolution, and doesn’t seem like it’s ever likely to end under this despotic regime.
And it’s funny (it’s not funny at all) that now these directors, and the actors, are in danger of being jailed or worse for making this flick, accused of all sorts of nonsense by the regime, and of being tools of outside influence, in the pay of American masters etc.
It’s as if they constantly re-forget that no-one hates and seeks to destroy the Iranian people more so than the Iranian regime.