Anatomy of a Fall
I wonder what he did in provoking someone into
doing this to him? Was it the way he was dressed,
maybe? Or maybe he'd been drinking?
Anatomie d’une chute
dir: Justine Triet
2023
Anatomy of a Fall is an odd film if what you think you’re getting is a crime / legal drama, which would be a reasonable assumption based on how it’s presented. And it won a bunch of awards, so you’d also think, since it’s a French film, that it must be all classy and shit.
But for a French film, there’s a surprising amount of dialogue in English. And the lead character is German. No one else speaks German, so she has to speak French, begrudgingly, and English when she can get away with it.
Which is, like, all of the time. I don’t pretend to know much about the French, but I do know two things: they laugh when non-French people try to speak French, and they pretend not to know English when people try to jabber at them without resorting to French.
And yet everyone seems cool with it, even her eleven year old son Daniel, who speaks no English whatsoever.
Strange vibes. But that’s not what the film is about. It’s on the surface about what happened to cause her husband Samuel to fall out of a window to his death.
On a deeper level maybe it’s about whether, if she did do it, was it an understandable thing to do? If not justifiable?
We spend a lot of time in a French court room, so the profound differences between their model and the ones we have in Britain or Australia are on display. As in another recentish film I watched mostly set in a French courtroom, being Saint Omer, the differences between the adversarial system we have in Australian courts and the inquisitorial system they have in France couldn’t be more stark.
To put it more simply, they say some crazy shit in court which wouldn’t fly in this hemisphere, let me tell you.
- Read more about Anatomy of a Fall
- 321 reads