Train Dreams

chop chop, those precious ecosystems aren't going
to destroy themselves
dir: Clint Bentley
2025
It’s being called one of the films of the year, which is all well and good, but now that I’ve watched it, it’s my time to pontificate about it.
It’s okay but it’s no masterpiece. It’s a very small film, not in scope or in terms of visuals, but in terms of being like a miniature portrait of a quiet man, who didn’t do much of anything, yet felt haunted all his live long life.
Sure, Robert Grainier (Joel Edgerton) worked as a logger and on the laying of tracks for a railroad in the Pacific North West, but you could hardly say he built the American empire that would take over that whole continent (and reduced those great forests to the 13% of the total that remain). And his whole life, as depicted here, has him more as bystander, observer to his own experiences, rather than active participant in the eight decades that he lives through.
It would not be fair to say he’s passive in the face of his own life, which spans much of the early twentieth century, but he really doesn’t do much, and all his struggles are mostly internal, and we’re told about them at great length via ceaseless voice over. I guess it would be impossible to do otherwise. Without it the majority of the flick would be Joel Edgerton standing around looking sad and / or pensive, and not saying much of anything, for decades. A lifetime of quiet desperation, if you will.
And that would be enough for a lot of people, including me. He’s really good at it (looking pensive, though he’s good at sitting or standing around as well). It’s not so much brooding as looking haunted. He is haunted from beginning to end, and maybe it’s not entirely his fault.
- Read more about Train Dreams
- 616 reads








