The Mastermind

I think the filmmakers are overestimating the attraction
of making Josh O'Connor look like Elliot Gould in
The Long Goodbye
dir: Kelly Reichardt
2025
Hmm.
I think the title is meant to be ironic.
The Mastermind is so low stakes, despite what the jazzy 70s soundtrack would have you believe, that it’s almost a comedy. Almost. But comedy implies funny, whereas this is too wry to be openly comedic.
The central guy JB, or mastermind, if you will, is a blank chap (played by Josh O’Connor) who lives a mundane suburban life with his wife (Alana Haim, in a thankless role) and two sons. She works, and he spends most days in his boxers, dreaming of something. He is an art school dropout, and a competent carpenter, but otherwise doesn’t work. Family visits to his parents, a conservative judge (Bill Camp) and doting mother (Hope Davis) infuriate him, even though he’s way too old to be a rebellious teen.
It’s meant to be important that this is set in the 1970s, specifically 1970. The mood is intense. The war in Vietnam is escalating, and an empowered Nixon makes it feel like the spirit of activism and rebellion deserves to be crushed under the jackboots and batons of the cops and the National Guard. Previously hopeful hippies and dissidents have fled, gone underground. The tide has turned, the mood has shifted.
I don’t really see how what JB does, which is, organise the theft of four paintings from a Framingham gallery somewhere in Massachusetts, has to do with any of that, but the theft all happens early in the movie, so there’s no build up, no carefully concocted plan with meticulous precision or any of that bullshit. It just happens, but then everything runs off the rails almost immediately.
The director isn’t interested in the heist – there is far more time spent watching JB trying to hide the paintings in carefully tailored cloth bindings and a well-constructed wooden box, that he stashes in the roof above a pig sty. And when I say that’s what she’s interested in, I mean she makes us watch as JB drives to the site, removes the box from the trunk of the car, remove the paintings from the box, climb a ladder clutching two of the paintings at a time, then carry the box up the ladder, then put the paintings back in the box, then hide the box under some straw.
Does that sound fascinating to you? Does that sound like an attack on American imperialism and the domestic malaise that middle America was suffering through way back when?
- Read more about The Mastermind
- 21 reads




























